Free shipping on orders over $75 ·  Free shipping on every subscription box  ·  500+ sauces from 90+ small-batch makers
Build your box

Shop by maker

Elijah's Xtreme

A father-and-son hot sauce company that launched in 2014, after Elijah spent years helping his dad grow superhot peppers from the age of five.

Elijah’s Xtreme has since won more than 50 industry awards. Regret and Regret Reserve are the headliners, packed with Carolina reaper and Trinidad scorpion, alongside Ghost Pepper, Reaper and the Yellowstone sauces. For something gentler, try the Original Roasted Pepper, Pineapple-Mango Habanero, the barbecue sauces or a reaper-infused hot honey.

13
In stock
Elijah's Xtreme

Showing 1–12 of 13 products

Hot sauce of the month club

Can’t decide? Let a curator pick

Set your heat level and flavors once, and get 1–3 small-batch bottles matched to you every month. Free shipping, never a repeat.

Build your box →

Showing 1–12 of 13 products

$0.00
0 items
View cart →

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Start with the burn you want. Every sauce is rated on one four-level scale.

Mild 118 Medium 189 Hot 98 Extra hot 76

Or let us choose: 1–3 bottles matched to your taste every month.

Build your box →