Free shipping on orders over $75 ·  Free shipping on every subscription box  ·  500+ sauces from 90+ small-batch makers
Build your box
Hot Ones S20 #6
Torchbearer Mushroom Mayhem Hot Sauce
Torchbearer Sauces

Mushroom Mayhem Hot Sauce

4.0 · 2 reviews
$11.99

In stock, ready to ship

Heat

Hot All hot →

Add $63.01 more for free shipping

Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout.

HEAT LEVEL: HOT

Hot Heat Level

Mushroom Mayhem – (Featured on season 20 of Hot Ones) It’s time to make savory foods even savory-er with our Mushroom Mayhem. This blend of shitake and portabella mushrooms with habanero and scorpion peppers brings a big heat and even bigger taste to our collection. You can’t beat a steak sandwich or a batch of wings slathered in this sauce. It’s also nice and thick so you can be sure it won’t be running all over the place, mixing into things it shouldn’t be mixing into (though, we aren’t really sure what those things could possibly be…). We really are loving this sauce and know you will too! Perfect For: Steak, Wings, Tofu

SIZE: 5 fl oz

Made with

Habanero Scorpion pepper Garlic
  • Ships within 48 hours from our warehouse in the USA
  • Tasted before we take a maker on, and every bottle is rated on our own heat scale
  • Free shipping over $75, calculated rate below that
Great with
SteakWingsTofu
Ingredients
Red Wine Vinegar, Tomato Paste, Water, Habanero Pepper, Brown Sugar, Scorpion Pepper, Mandarin Orange, Horseradish, Garlic, Molasses, Black Pepper, Salt, Shitake Mushroom Powder, Portabella Mushroom Powder, All-Spice, Paprika
Specs
  • Heat Hot on the SCOVILLED scale
  • Maker Torchbearer Sauces
  • Peppers Habanero, Scorpion
  • As seen on Hot Ones, Season 20 #6
Shipping & returns

Orders ship within 48 hours from the USA. Free shipping on orders over $75; below that a calculated rate is shown at checkout. See our shipping policy and refund policy.

Torchbearer Mushroom Mayhem Hot Sauce
$11.99
Three small-batch hot sauce bottles from a SCOVILLED monthly subscription box

Hot sauce of the month club

Like heat like this? Get it picked for you every month

If Mushroom Mayhem is your speed, tell us that once and stop hunting. Set your heat level, the flavors you want, and the food you actually cook. Then a real person picks 1, 2 or 3 small-batch bottles for you every month.

  • Curated by a person, not an algorithm, and never the same sauce twice
  • Free shipping on every box, from $18.95/mo
  • Skip or cancel anytime, with no phone call or retention hoops
Build your box →How the box works

Reviews

What people say about this sauce

4.0
Based on 2 reviews
5 star 1
4 star 0
3 star 1
2 star 0
1 star 0

About the maker

Torchbearer Sauces

Pennsylvania’s TorchBearer Sauces has been making bold, all-natural sauces since 2005, and it’s a Hot Ones regular.

Founded in Mechanicsburg by three friends, TorchBearer made its name with Garlic Reaper, built on its mild Oh My Garlic! sauce, which became a Hot Ones favorite. Superhots like Zombie Apocalypse, Son of Zombie and Ultimate Annihilation sit at the top of a huge range that also has plenty of mild and medium bottles, like Sweet Onion Habanero, Honey Badger, Headless Horseradish and Danny Wood Jalapeño, plus barbecue and wing sauces.

Shop all Torchbearer Sauces sauces →

What hot actually means

Where this sits on the scale

30,000–350,000 SHU on the SCOVILLED scale. Habanero territory: heat that lingers, with room left for flavor.

Newer to heat? Start with medium instead.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Start with the burn you want. Every sauce is rated on one four-level scale.

Mild 117 Medium 186 Hot 95 Extra hot 75

Or let us choose: 1–3 bottles matched to your taste every month.

Build your box →